A few months ago, I wrote an article of packaging materials for online sellers and in it I go over the best options for different products – boxes, jiffy bags, mailing bags etc. BUT since then, I’ve received probably hundreds of emails from sellers asking me where to buy this stuff?
So I’ve decided to, once and for all, create a full comparison for you that you can refer to whenever you need to order packaging materials!
In this guide I’ll be comparing the big 3 options – eBay, Amazon and ecommerce sellers. But I won’t just say “go to eBay”, no – I will tell you exactly where you should go to get the cheapest price possible for your packaging, after all – overspending here won’t give you any benefits for your business and it’s simply an unnecessary expense.
Let’s get to it!
The jiffy bag I’m going to be researching is probably the most commonly used by eBay sellers – the JL1 170mm x 245mm (‘DVD size’).
Now I always like to start my research on eBay, as it’s the quickest and easiest way to compare multiple sellers at once and to get a good idea of the average pricing, whereas in comparison you would have to go through hundreds of ecommerce stores.
So I start off by simply searching JL1 jiffy on eBay.
Now ignoring the multi-item listings for now I can straight away see that the price for 100 of these on eBay is around £11 (a little bit less).
Next I’ll go through the first few results, which were multi-item listings, and see if any of them offer better pricing.
And yes, I find 100 of the same size JL1 jiffy bags for just £8.99 delivered:
But as you may have noticed, these are described as “jiffy-style” in the description title which means it isn’t an official Jiffy Airkraft but as it’s simply a padded envelope (your customers certainly won’t notice the absence of the Airkraft logo on the back) and most importantly, the seller has very good feedback (99.9% positive with just under 80k feedback), I think it’s safe to assume they’ll be of a good enough quality.
But in the interest of fairness I’ll also note that the cheapest actual JL1 Airkraft Jiffy bags that can be bought on eBay are here, at £19.39 for 200.
That gives a price of just under £0.10 per jiffy bag.
Next let’s move onto Amazon and see if any sellers there can beat our eBay pricing.
Here we can see fairly quickly that there isn’t anything too competitive on offer for Airkraft jiffy bags:
But there is a listing for the slightly larger Mail Lite equivalent (Mail Lite are the other major manufacturer) at only £9.99 delivered for 100, which is a pretty good price considering these are also a little bit bigger at 180mm x 260mm.
So far eBay and Amazon have been pretty equal with a few different options (Mail Lite vs Airkraft vs Unbranded) so last but not least, let’s see if there are any eCommerce stores that can beat them.
I search on Google and click on one of the sponsored adwords listings at the top which takes me to cheap-integratedlabels.co.uk where they’re selling own-brand white padded envelopes and initially, the prices seem AMAZING!
I mean, £6.43 for a box of 100 is far cheaper than eBay or Amazon…
BUT from experience I know that’s too good to be true and as expected, after adding it to basket – the full price comes up, putting the single box at £14.50 after VAT and shipping have been added:
So please always bear this in mind when searching on eCommerce stores – most of the time the price shown is ex-VAT and before shipping, which is exactly why I said earlier that it’s always easiest to start on eBay due to how easy it is to compare different sellers.
But now, let’s see if we can find a cheaper offer anywhere else…
Well unfortunately not as nearly all the eCommerce stores I checked were either much more expensive or at best, still a bit more at around £11+ per box of 100.
One store, firststoppackaging.co.uk, did have some very good pricing of £9.55 per box of 100 Mail Lite D/1 envelopes, but they only offered free shipping on orders of £25 and above, which means ordering 3 boxes at once.
That would cost you £28.65 which is 9.6p per jiffy, BUT if ordering 300 at once, it would still be cheaper to use the Amazon seller as the shipping cost decreases with larger orders:
And that means that at the end of Round 1 of our price comparison, it’s a draw between eBay and Amazon.
Amazon is the best option for branded jiffy bags, with 100 Mail Lite D/1 180 x 260mm envelopes available for £9.99 delivered from the seller A2B Stationery Limited:
But if you don’t mind going for a non-branded option, then eBay seller packaging_monkey is your best bet, with a hundred costing just £8.99:
The next item up for comparison is the ever-reliable cardboard box.
Of course, as with jiffy bags, there are countless sizes available, so in order to make it a fair comparison – I’m going to be looking at the maximum sized cardboard box for Royal Mail’s small parcel pricing, which is now 45cm x 35cm x 16cm.
As before, let’s head to eBay first to get started!
But before that, let me quickly state that with cardboard boxes, you can get either single wall or double wall, and there’s a big difference in quality (as well as price!).
As the name suggests, double wall offers much more protection and is suitable for heavier and more fragile items, so please bear that in mind when you’re doing your research.
Okay, on eBay the best price for the new RM small parcel sized boxes are from globe_packaging, with 25 boxes for £17.75, 50 boxes for £32.70 and 100 boxes for £57:
As you can see, in this case you save about 20% on the cost per box if you buy 100 instead of 25, and that’s the case with pretty much all packaging supplies – the more you buy at once, the lower the price you get.
And that’s why I always suggest buying as much as you can at one time. Use your common sense of course as the last thing you want to do is blow your entire start up budget on boxes, but when you’re at the stage that you know you’re going to be needing, say, 200 of these boxes in the next few months, then buy two hundred at once.
Not only does this save you money, it also means you don’t have to constantly worry about your packaging supplies and can concentrate on the more important aspects of your business.
Next onto Amazon and here it takes a slight loss against eBay as there is only one seller for this box size and their pricing isn’t as competitive as Globe Packaging.
They offer 25 boxes for £21.49, 50 boxes for £34.99 and 100 boxes for £59.99 so in all instances it’s cheaper to buy from eBay and really that’s to be expected considering the lack of competition for packaging materials on Amazon.
And then finally, we move onto eCommerce again to see if any site can stop eBay getting another win.
Unfortunately once again the answer is no… after going through multiple pages of Google search results I was unable to find anywhere that could match the pricing on eBay, and that includes Globe Packaging’s own eCommerce store, where pricing is significantly higher than what they offer on eBay:
And that means that for round 2, our winner is eBay!
Time to test the pricing for mailing bags now! Mailing bags are already an incredibly cost-effective packaging material so I wouldn’t spend too much time trying to shave off those extra pennies!
For this example we’ll be researching 12” x 16” (305mm x 405mm) grey mailing bags and as before, we’ll start with eBay:
The cheapest listing for a small quantity of 100 is packaging.products.direct at £6.49 delivered.
And then if you want a larger quantity of 500 mailing bags, neopostal works out a fair bit cheaper at £22.99 or 1000 pieces for £35.95.
So as you can see, mailing bags really are incredibly cheap with a cost per piece of around 3.5 pence on a tiny £35 order.
Of course this is because they offer much less protection than cardboard boxes or even jiffy bags and are not suitable for all products but if you do sell something that would be okay to post in a mailing bag, then that’s a great way to save some money on postage costs.
And now onto Amazon and for the smaller quantity of 100, there is a seller offering them for just £5.13 delivered, which is 20% cheaper than eBay!
However for the higher quantities, there aren’t many sellers on Amazon and none come close to the pricing on eBay.
And finally with eCommerce it was more of the same (I’m starting to sense a pattern here!) and even when going up to quantities of 5000+ I couldn’t reach the per piece price of neopostal on eBay.
Which means that overall round 3 goes to eBay, with Amazon slightly cheaper if you only needed a very small amount.
And that’s it for our price comparison of the 3 main postage materials for online sellers – jiffy bags, cardboard boxes and mailing bags.
To be honest the results are pretty much exactly as I expected, with eBay cheapest on most occasions (though sometimes Amazon if there’s a good deal on) and ecommerce stores simply unable to compete on price.
That is why I have always said “go to eBay” for your packaging supplies!
eBay is the place to get items as cheap as possible and that doesn’t change here…
Only if you’re ordering HUGE quantities or need custom cut boxes or custom printed mailing bags should you start looking into other suppliers.
Until then stick to eBay as I’ve always maintained (though I hope you’ll finally believe me after these real-life examples!).
Just to make it a complete price comparison for shipping materials, we’ll take one final look at a couple of must-have items – bubble wrap and packing tape!
Bubble wrap is usually sold in rolls so there are two measurements you need to look at when buying – one is the width which is usually either 300mm, 500mm, or 750mm and the other is the length which is basically how long the roll is.
So if you’re wrapping large items, go for the wider roll but for smaller items the 300mm roll will be easier to use…
In this example, we’ll use the middle ground of 500mm wide bubble wrap.
Note – there are also different sized bubble roles but as small bubbles are by far the most common for online sellers, that’s what we’ll be researching here.
On eBay the cheapest seller for a 50m long 500mm wide roll is postal-online at just £5.75.
It goes without saying that 50m is a LOT of bubble wrap (the length of two swimming pools!) so again, the cost is really negligible per item sent.
Amazon once again beats eBay by a very small margin, with PolyPostalBags offering the same amount of bubble wrap for £5.26.
As you’ve probably already guessed, online stores outside of eBay and Amazon were unable to compete on price and most of the time were at least 2-3 times more expensive…
That brings us to the final item in our price comparison –
The most common roll size for packing tape is probably 48mm wide x 66m and just like with bubble wrap, the cost per item posted is miniscule.
You can pick up 12 of these rolls for £6.48 on eBay.
Considering that a single roll last hundreds of orders, this is very much an order once and forget about it item!
On this occasion most sellers on Amazon are offering Scotch branded tape, which as you would expect is a fair bit more expensive:
It feels like a foregone conclusion at this point, and as expected – I couldn’t find any ecommerce stores that could compete on price with eBay.
So that brings our pricing comparison to an end.
To conclude; it’s as I’ve always said – the cheapest suppliers for packaging materials are nearly always on eBay (and occasionally Amazon but the choice is far less).
You could possibly find cheaper suppliers online if you spent hours upon hours searching but then, what’s the point? Simply head to eBay, and order it from there, knowing that you’re 99.9% getting the best price available.
Now I know what you may be thinking – but the quality on eBay is probably really bad?
And to a degree, yes that’s true. On average the materials you buy from eBay will be worse that the branded ones available online but as long as they do the job, then that’s fine!
As you can see, all the sellers featured here have great feedback so it’s extremely unlikely that you’ll receive products that aren’t fit for use.
So that leaves me to conclude that unless you’re ordering HUGE quantities or need very specific packaging materials (such as custom sizes, colours or printing) then just keep things simple and order from eBay!
After all, this is by no means something that will make or break your business so just order enough supplies to last you a few months at least and then get on with more important things in your business – like making sales so that you actually have a use for all that tape and bubble wrap ;-).
Until next time!
All the best,